三年级原名:CE2,又名The Third Grade
Claire and Kevin both attend a French village school. They are in the same class, CE2, for children aged eight and nine. Claire is the target of constant bullying by Kevin and his friends, and this is even starting to get violent. It seems very difficult to do anything about it – reporting it to the teacher or parents often backfires. When her mother finally takes action, it be...
#IFFR51# Big Screen Competition。前面几乎是恐怖片了……校园霸凌不少见,拍得既纯真可爱,又让人浑身难受,也是挺不容易的;然而做完阶级分析之后,画风突转成一个“喜欢你就要欺负你”的两小无猜甜文有点不适应,加上结尾也真有点拧巴……导演不愧是能调教出来4岁就拿***影后的高手(这部掉到鹿特丹大银幕也是有点……当然肯定三大主竞赛是不够的,可能更适合柏林Generation K),这里面小孩子戏还真不错……
杜瓦隆的电影常常处于真空状态,除了人物当下所为之外,其他什么都没有。《三年级》从孩子们常见的道德行为出发,呈现但不施加立场,对人物的厌恶和理解得以共存。
前三分之一挺紧凑,三分之二开始有点摸不着头脑,但好歹能看下去,最后半个小时,如坐针毡,结尾,不知所云。小孩子说大人话,大人耍小孩子性。作者的自恋到了在每个人物身上都有投射的地步。片子很美,小演员很灵,但对于导演,夸不出口。
4.5 机械、僵硬的人物状态碰撞,最终也形成了渐进式自然且轻巧、流畅的情境,在平缓的结构中间歇地安插激进的局部,这种异质明显的交融方式非得是以小孩子戏才能构成,后半段渐入佳境,真好看啊。 可类比《小索朗日》和《一万二欧元》。